Showing posts with label BMHR. Show all posts
Showing posts with label BMHR. Show all posts

Monday, September 19, 2011

Would I recommend bilateral BMHRs?

johnnybravo84 said...
Hi Lori, I'm in need of bilateral hip replacement due to Avascular Necrosis in both femoral heads. My Doctors in Madison, Wisconsin, USA, has advised me to consider BMHR and am thinking about flying overseas to get it. Have looked at Dr. McMinn in Birmingham, UK and Dr. Bose in Chennai, India. Just wondering if you would summerize your entire experience thus far as a good one. Also, would you advise to do both hips at once, or did it prove to be somewhat "too much"? Thanks in advance for your reply!

Short answer:  Yes, the experience has been positive for me and I think if you can do both at once, it is worth serious consideration.

The long answer:  Even though I had a pretty rough time immediately post-op, I don't regret the decision that I made.  I made the right decision and I am already seeing just how much more I will be able to do.  I'm not a medical professional and my experiences are my own and are going to be individual to my particular case but I hope that sharing these will help others in both the decision making and rehabilitation process.

I'm happy to hear that your doctors have given you options that aren't just within their realm of expertise and services that they provide.  From some of the stories that I have heard, it isn't the norm unfortunately.  If you are a candidate for a BMHR, I would certainly recommend this over a THR based two things that were important to me: the BMHR is more bone conserving allowing for easier revision many many years in the future and the information I've read indicates that there are less restrictions on this prosthesis as compared to many total hip devices.   If '84 is your year of birth, I'd give your doctor's suggestion some serious thought.  Conserve as much bone as you can - you don't know what will be around in 20+ years when you need revision.

As part of the pre-op process, I signed authority to the surgeon to make the final call on this once he'd cut.  There was a small chance that I would need a total hip.  I wouldn't have wanted just any surgeon make this call. It was the first question I asked when I woke up.  I probably got a little too invested in the BMHR being the solution for me but my research had made me extremely positive about this option as being the 'one' for me.

My reasons for requiring hip replacement were related to damage caused by juvenile arthritis.  The damage had been there for a large number of years and my body had been compensating for this damage for almost as many years.  It has been explained to me that how our bodies recover very much depends on the condition that we are going in.

I don't know much about AVN so it really is hard for me to compare our experiences so that I can  have a guess at how well you will feel post surgery.  The two surgeons that you have mentioned are leaders in the field and I am sure that they will be able to give you a far better indication as to when you will be up for travelling home after the surgery.

I have seen a lot of information relating to travel and surgery on a discussion forum called Surface Hippy though most relates to BHRs.  Though not completely the same there are a lot of similarities in our recovery processes and some of the experiences that the members who have AVN and travelled might help with your decision making process.  The people are awesome there and no matter which decision that you make, I would highly recommend posting your question as they will have a lot of helpful things to add about the process that might differ from mine.

I have come across one BMHR lady who travelled on a forum.  It's only relatively new and there aren't as many people there so I'm not sure how successful you will be in contacting her there.  Rosemary references being a part of the yahoo group hipresurfacingsite so she may respond to a message there.  (I haven't really used yahoo groups as I loved the surface hippy group of people)  She travelled to McMinn for a ceramic BMHR recently and had her early recovery time in the UK away from home.  If you can find her, I'm sure that her story will be of great interest to you.   From what I can gather she spent about four weeks in the UK before travelling.  I would expect for bilateral, it should be at least that.  At that time, I don't think I could have handled a long plane trip home though from the stories I have read, many resurfacing patients have done it sooner - so it is possible.

You can't get better than Bose or McMinn.  There are a few others in their league though given the choice and that you have to travel anyway, why not go for the best!  McMinn was involved with the development of the BMHR and has the longest history of using them.  If you haven't already, read every page of his website! 

I believe that I couldn't have coped with one at a time as I would have chosen my right side to be done first, my left unoperated leg would have been the 'good' leg, the one that I would rely on a lot more.  I don't think it would have held up and actually quickly become the one that let me down and caused pain.  I don't think that I would have had the same opportunity for long term successes with one at a time, though this is really a gut feeling.  Unfortunately there is no 'control group' for scientific exploration of what is the best option for anyones exact particular experiences.   

The one thing that I wish I knew going in was that I was allergic to the hard drugs.  If I hadn't of had the hallucinations and nausea from the endone and oxycontin, I think that I would have had a bit more of a kick start the recovery process.  It might not have put me too much ahead now and there will be little difference by the time my new parts are a year old but I think that mentally/emotionally I would have been better off.  Major surgery is major surgery and if you have trouble with the meds or any other complications it's going to happen with one side or two.   Both at once means that your risk periods are going to finish at the same time and at twelve months you are going to have two new hips working well where as if you did one, the old one will probably need to be done by then starting the whole process over again.

Attitude is a big part of the recovery process for bilats.  You need to be prepared to put in the hard yards and fight to stay positive and do whatever you need to do get the best possible outcomes.  It is harder but I don't think it's 'twice' as hard.  There were moments where I thought I made the wrong decision though this was in the early days where I just felt like absolute shit.  I think the memories of this are already fading though as my husband chastised me the other day for saying something was worse than hip replacement (Mildly of course!).  He couldn't understand how I could speak so flippantly about that time.  I guess the good that I can see now outweighs that time so much so that the memories have faded. 

I really thought it would be easier than what it was.  In that regard, my expectations were a little unreasonable.  Time is the only thing that I've been off with though.  Everything else is looking great and I don't regret it at all.  In a way, my timing was right as the other set expectation was that at three months out, I was no worse of than pre-op.  At that time I was significantly better in a number of areas.  I guess that I just didn't quite realise exactly what that would mean.  The piece of wisdom that can be gleaned from this, it is probably not wise to set conflicting expectations!

I did this at the best time for me and the outcomes so far have been stellar.  I'm no longer on pain or anti-inflammatory meds.  I have a range of movement that I don't ever remember having.  I'm already doing things that I couldn't do before and though these might seem minor to some, these are huge to me.  I still have another 7 months of improvements before the progress levels off and I'm expecting big things!

I wish you well on your search for information to help make your decision.  Please feel free to ask any other questions that you might have.  Please keep us posted as to what you decide to do and how you go!

Monday, September 12, 2011

Surgical Review Day

I was actually on time to see Paul this morning even though it has probably been the earliest appointment that I have ever had at the clinic.  Some of the muscles are already better than they were pre-op and everything else is coming along nicely.  I was pretty confident that the day was going according to schedule when I arrived in at the hospital before 10am even after stopping for a takeaway coffee on the way.

I headed into QScan to get the x-rays required for my appointment, only their machine was broken and I had to find my way to QLD X-ray to have them done.  After a few navigational errors, I found myself ready for a long wait.  At a few minutes before my appointment I wasn't sure that I was going to make it since my x-rays hadn't come back yet.  Thankfully the surgeon's office was still going to let me come to see him even though I was late.  A few people had already been delayed by the same issue so it turned out ok.  I really should have gone to have them done on a completely different day to allow for things to go wrong and though I would have been disappointed to reschedule, I would have understood.

The surgeon is happy with my progress so far and I got told to keep doing what I'm doing.  The x-rays look good and I'm due again for review on 9 April next year.  Providing there isn't anything requiring closer monitoring, I will go onto an annual review schedule from there on in.  

I asked the question about the ranges and was told that I'm actually doing ok with them and will continue to see improvements until at least the 12 month mark.  How far I actually get is going to depend on not only what I do, but the condition pre-operatively is going to affect the outcomes.  I did understand this going in and already everything is better than it was going in, but I am still optimistic that there is more that I can get out of this.  The flexion estimate is about another 10 degrees active (around 100 - 105 degrees).  Apparently what I have now is on par with the outcomes of a lot of total hips that are in the condition that mine were pre-operatively.  I see this as a positive sign for my progress this far.  It makes me feel a little bit better about not being on par with the BHRs and other resurfacing components on a number of discussion groups.  This doesn't often bother me, but every now and then it's nice to be reminded not to compare too closely.  I started off a long way behind them and I think that in the long run I will be far better off as I don't have the 'hey day' to compare my achievements with.  I was never a ballet dancer or a taekwondo black belt that I'm aspiring to be again. These people are likely to recover to a higher standard as they are likely to be in better condition going in but the loss of even just a little bit is going to hurt.  I am all gains, which to me, seems to be the better view.

I also saw a ceramic BMHR.  I even touched it.  They are pretty.  I think my shiny MOM component is better looking but the ceramic is nice (Not that you choose these items for cosmetic reasons!).  Dr Journeaux has done one of these in the public health system so far.  They haven't been approved for use by the private system yet even though the MOM's are (Of those his count is over a hundred and for the BHRs, I think it was nearing a thousand).  Still early days for all surgeons doing them though it is all positive (I linked to McMinn's info on the Ceramic BMHR over the weekend).  There are no revisions for BMHRs for my surgeon at this time which I think is a really good sign.  It means it's tracking well with the longer term statistics available for the BHR.

There are always changes in this field and regardless of what happens next, I got what I needed and at the right time.  The common consensus seems to be that it will be for a long time too!

I'm starting to get a little tired.  Probably due to the change in routine for today.  Though I tried to get to sleep at a normal hour last night, it really didn't work out since I'm used to later nights and later mornings.  I'm sure I've probably missed something in the summary of today, so feel free to ask questions.  If I think of anything more I'll add a new post later!

Saturday, September 10, 2011

Ceramic BMHRs

The McMinn Centre has released some information about the Ceramic BMHR.  This is pretty exciting for people that have metal allergies that preclude them from being suitable candidates for the MOM BMHR or resurfacing.  I'm sure we'll see more information about this prosthesis as it becomes available!

Friday, August 12, 2011

Derek McMinn addresses Metal on Metal AZ May 2011

Patient Advocate of BHR's, Vicky Marlow has interviewed Mr Derek McMinn at the recent Arizona Orthopaedic Conference and compiled the information on her site here:  McMinn on Metal on Metal

I haven't read the information in full yet as I'm in the process of actually getting a post together covering what has happened this week.  I'm sure it will be an educational read.

Saturday, June 18, 2011

What the BMHR's look like / Where they are now


I have digital copies of xrays that were taken on the day of my surgical review.  I can open them in a piece of free software called OsiriX and export them into a format that I can open in photoshop to remove the pieces that I don't particularly want to show everyone.  I've also rotated the image so that the left is on the left (which probably doesn't make sense - but hey I'm new to this and am having fun playing!).  When I have a bit more time I'll have another go at getting some clearer copies up that haven't been cropped so tightly (that was to hide the outline of my body, which I'm sure can be removed with a little bit more work.  This process also had the side effect of darkening the detail of the femurs, so I need to go about the process a little bit differently).  In the meantime, I thought I'd upload something so you can see my new parts in place!

Saturday, May 28, 2011

Mr McMinn comments on ABC's Four Corners bash up of hip resurfacing

There was a recent Four Corners program that was rather negative about hip resurfacing and metal on metal prostheses.  It focuses on the ASR device that has been recalled and applies these statistics across a field of other devices that have had significant success.  (Like the side note of the post 'Six Week Surgical Review', the negative effects of metal ions are overstated compared with research based evidence using larger sample sizes)

Mr McMinn responds to the program with an article on his website: http://www.mcminncentre.co.uk/response-abc-corners-program.html
(McMinn invented the BMHR that I have and has had great successes with his previous invention the BHR resurfacing device.  He is regarded as an expert in the field by many and above average survivorship rates clearly support this)

The key statements that resonated with me are:
"It would be unfortunate if the adverse results from a few ill-designed, poorly implanted devices are allowed to throw this excellent treatment option into disrepute."
"It must be remembered however that component malposition is a cause of failure and should be avoided. Choose your device and your surgeon carefully."  

Well designed, well implanted devices have changed so many lives for the better.  I hope that people looking at resurfacing consider all the research out there and not just the sensational media reports.

Thursday, March 3, 2011

The Birmingham Mid Head Resection (BMHR)

The goal is to have a left and right Birmingham Mid Head Resection (BMHR) completed on the 8th April.

After the right hip is completed, the surgeon and anaesthetist will chat and make sure that all is good to proceed with the left.  The right is where I experience most of the pain and it will be a great relief to be without this, though I will be very disappointed if I wake up with just one done.  Obviously the doctors will make the decision based on what is best for me and I would rather wake up disappointed than take unnecessary risk.

Depending on the bone quality and the degree that the protrusio affects the procedure, the surgeon may elect to complete a total hip replacement instead.  This again is not ideal as the BMHR is preferred for younger more active patients. The surgeon has suggested that I take a look at the McMinn Centre website for more information and I have found the site a wealth of information.  An update in recent months includes a lot more video testimonials which are interesting to watch.  I would like some more from some less active people (ie. not highly sporting).